TOTAL VOLUME:

$164.7b

24H VOL:

$148,169,742

24H TRANSACTIONS:

3,258,908,236

OPEN INTEREST:

$1,658,654,544

346,710

Markets across

38,022

events

MATCHED EVENTS:

3,752

PLATFORM COVERAGE:

5

Polymarket:

36%

VS.

Kalshi:

64%

BETA
Dashboards
Insights
Tour
All
Featured
#Polymarket#Regulation#Prediction Markets#Education

Is Polymarket Legal in New York? (2026)

Polymarket US is still available in New York, but the state's Attorney General is suing it and Polymarket has sued back. No court has ruled yet.

Jared P headshot

Jared Polites

Nov 8, 2026

PredictionHero article image: Is Polymarket legal in New York? (2026)

TL;DR

  • Polymarket US, the CFTC-regulated app run by QCX LLC, is still listed as available in New York. No court has ordered it to stop.
  • On September 24, 2026, Attorney General Letitia James sued Polymarket US, alleging an unlicensed gambling operation. Polymarket says federal law gives the CFTC exclusive authority and sued New York the same day.
  • The international site, polymarket.com, is not open to US users. Polymarket's developer docs put the United States in the "close-only" group.
  • New York is the one state in this series where a case names Polymarket. "Legal" here means available and contested, not settled.

Are you in New York and wondering whether it's safe to open a Polymarket account right now? Polymarket US is still available, but the state says it is operating illegally, and a court hasn't decided who is right.

That makes this page different from our other state guides. The prediction market data on Polymarket US is live, while the legal question is in active litigation. Below is what each side says, what the courts have done so far, and what could change. It isn't legal advice, and the facts move quickly.

Is Polymarket Legal in New York?

It is available, and contested. Polymarket US is operated by QCX LLC, which the CFTC lists as a designated contract market. DeFi Rate's New York page, updated November 4, 2026, lists Polymarket US as available in the state.

The state disagrees that it is lawful. New York's Attorney General says Polymarket's markets are gambling and that it runs without a New York State Gaming Commission license. Polymarket says it operates under federal law and is staying in New York.

No court has ruled on either position. As of the tracker DeFi Rate captured on November 7, 2026, the court record shows a September 30 order that required a joint letter and neither paused the case nor ruled on the merits.

Which Polymarket Can New Yorkers Use?

Only Polymarket US. Polymarket's developer docs list the United States as a close-only country on polymarket.com. Users there can close existing positions but cannot open new ones.

Polymarket US is a separate product with its own rulebook. The CFTC issued an amended order of designation in November 2025, which let QCX operate as an intermediated platform. Our guide to using Polymarket in the US walks through sign-up and funding.

The two products also differ on identity checks. The international site lets you connect a wallet without government ID. Polymarket US requires full identity verification before you can fund an account.

For the full record on the company, including the 2022 CFTC order, see our Polymarket legitimacy review.

What Is New York's Case Against Polymarket?

On September 24, 2026, Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul announced a lawsuit against QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US. The state says Polymarket's markets meet the legal definition of gambling and that the company has no license from the Gaming Commission.

It also says Polymarket lets users aged 18 to 20 take part, while New York requires users of mobile sports betting to be 21. James has called prediction markets "quintessentially gambling."

The state asks for an order stopping the operation, fines, forfeiture of gains, restitution to consumers and fines of three times the gains. DeFi Rate reports the petition was filed in New York County Supreme Court under Executive Law Section 63(12) and also seeks $100,000 per unauthorized sports-wagering offer.

These are the state's allegations. They are not findings.

What Does Polymarket Say, and What Is Its Countersuit?

Polymarket's position is that the CFTC has exclusive authority over prediction markets. Hours after the state filed, it sued New York in federal court in Manhattan. It asked for a declaration that New York cannot enforce its civil and criminal gambling laws against the company.

Its filing calls the state's action "an extraordinary assertion of state power squarely foreclosed by federal law," according to Reuters. Chief Legal Officer Neal Kumar said: "We believe in New York and we're staying here."

Polymarket also moved the state case to the federal Southern District of New York the same day, per DeFi Rate's report. That decides where the case is heard, not whether the contracts comply with state law.

Is This the Same Fight New York Has With Kalshi?

Largely, yes. New York sued Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan in April 2026, then Kalshi on July 31. The Polymarket case is the latest in that series, and the legal question is the same one: whether federally regulated event contracts can be reached by a state's gambling laws.

Both platforms are CFTC-regulated, and each says it operates lawfully under federal law. Our Kalshi New York guide covers that case and the July 7 federal ruling in it. Kalshi lost its request to block New York's enforcement in that ruling, but the decision doesn't bind the Polymarket case directly.

Do Federal Courts Settle the Question Yet?

No. Appeals courts have gone both ways, and none of these rulings involved Polymarket.

CourtStateDateOutcome
Third CircuitNew JerseyApril 2026For Kalshi; sports contracts treated as swaps under CFTC jurisdiction
Southern District of New YorkNew YorkJuly 7, 2026Against Kalshi; federal law doesn't preempt New York's gambling rules for these contracts
Ninth CircuitNevadaAugust 28, 2026Against Kalshi; federal law doesn't preempt Nevada's gaming rules for these contracts
Sixth CircuitOhio, TennesseeSeptember 25, 2026Against Kalshi; Kalshi hadn't shown its sports contracts are swaps

New York sits in the Second Circuit. I found no Second Circuit merits ruling. Our guide to prediction market regulation maps how the CFTC and the states divide this territory.

Could Polymarket Become Unavailable in New York?

It could, and the routes are worth knowing. A federal judge could rule for the state. The state could win an injunction. Polymarket could also choose to change its New York offering. A Supreme Court decision on sports contracts could change the options for every state.

The counterweight is the federal framework. Polymarket US trades on a CFTC-designated exchange, and Polymarket's lawsuit asks a federal court to say New York can't enforce its laws against it.

None of that has happened yet. If you trade there, watch for a ruling on the declaration Polymarket seeks, any order on the state's request for an injunction, and the Second Circuit's decision in the Kalshi appeal. Our California, Texas and Washington guides show how other states compare.

How Does Polymarket Compare With the Other Platforms for New Yorkers?

Polymarket is the largest crypto-native platform, and its US product is the regulated way in for New York residents. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange too, with bank and card funding, and it is in a parallel New York case.

Opinion, Limitless and Predict.Fun are on-chain platforms. New York-specific action against those three is not publicly documented.

PredictionHero tracks all five. Our guide to where to find prediction market data explains each source and its limits.

For a head-to-head, see our Polymarket and Kalshi comparison. For the broader question of how the category is classified, see our guide on whether Polymarket is gambling.

Polymarket US, the CFTC-regulated app, is listed as available to eligible New Yorkers, but the state's Attorney General sued it in September 2026 and Polymarket countersued. No court has ruled. Treat Polymarket prices as prediction market data without legal clearance, and check the app's eligibility screen.

No. Polymarket's developer docs put the United States in the close-only group, so users can close existing positions but cannot open new ones. New Yorkers who want to trade use Polymarket US instead, a separate product that requires identity verification before you can fund an account.

Yes. On September 24, 2026, Attorney General James sued QCX LLC, which operates Polymarket US, alleging an unlicensed gambling operation and access for users aged 18 to 20. Polymarket disputes this, argues federal law governs, and filed its own federal suit against New York the same day.

Not on the merits. A September 30, 2026 order asked the parties for a joint letter and did not pause the case or decide who is right, according to DeFi Rate's tracker. Rulings in other states involve Kalshi, not Polymarket, and appeals courts have split.

It's possible if a court rules for the state or Polymarket changes its offering. Polymarket's chief legal officer said the company is staying, and it is asking a federal court to bar enforcement. Nothing has forced a change so far, and the case could take months or longer.

Sources

  • New York Attorney General. "Attorney General James and Governor Hochul Announce Lawsuit Against Polymarket for Running Illegal Gambling Operation." September 24, 2026. ag.ny.gov
  • Reuters. "New York, Polymarket sue each other over whether prediction markets are illegal gambling." September 24, 2026. lufkindailynews.com
  • Front Office Sports. "New York Pulls Polymarket Into Legal Battle." September 24, 2026. frontofficesports.com
  • DeFi Rate. "New York Sues Polymarket US Over Sports, Election and Culture Contracts." September 25, 2026. defirate.com
  • DeFi Rate. "New York Prediction Markets: Latest Updates and Apps." Updated November 4, 2026. defirate.com
  • CFTC. "Designated Contract Markets: QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US." cftc.gov
  • Polymarket. "Geoblock." Developer documentation. docs.polymarket.com
  • U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. KalshiEX LLC v. New York State Gaming Commission et al., No. 1:25-cv-08846, Opinion and Order, July 7, 2026. ag.ny.gov
  • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. KalshiEX LLC v. Flaherty, No. 25-1922, decided April 6, 2026. justia.com
  • Holland & Knight. "Ninth Circuit Upholds State and Tribal Authority Over Sports-Related Event Contracts." August 2026. hklaw.com
  • DeFi Rate. "Sixth Circuit Rules Against Kalshi, Lets Ohio and Tennessee Enforce Sports Betting Laws." defirate.com

PredictionHero aggregates publicly available prediction market data for informational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Prediction markets may not be available in all jurisdictions.

Related


PredictionHero article image: Is Kalshi legal in New York? (2026)
Featured

Is Kalshi Legal in New York? (2026)

Kalshi is still available in New York, but the state has beaten it in federal court and is now suing it. Here's the real status, and what could change it.

Jared P headshot

Jared Polites · Oct 18

PredictionHero article image: Is Polymarket legit?
Featured

Is Polymarket Legit? What the Data and the Regulatory Record Actually Show (2026)

Yes, Polymarket is a legitimate, well-funded exchange that pays out onchain. Here's the full record, good and bad.

Jared P headshot

Jared Polites · Sep 25

How to Use Polymarket in the US — Legal Status and Setup
Featured

How to Use Polymarket in the US (Legal Status, Setup, and a Safer Path)

Polymarket now runs a CFTC-regulated US product through its QCX exchange. Here's how it actually works, who's eligible, and when Kalshi is the better fit instead.

Jared P headshot

Jared Polites · Aug 14