TOTAL VOLUME:

$134.2b

24H VOL:

$126,324,530

24H TRANSACTIONS:

2,388,728,490

OPEN INTEREST:

$1,434,646,834

406,019

Markets across

30,401

events

MATCHED EVENTS:

2,689

PLATFORM COVERAGE:

5

Polymarket:

39%

VS.

Kalshi:

61%

BETA
Dashboards
Tour
All
Sports
Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cleveland Guardians
predict
kalshi
polymarket

Who will win Pittsburgh Pirates vs Cleveland Guardians?

Volume:
$6,276,351

Pittsburgh

all

3 markets

Kalshi

Polymarket

Predict

consensus

News

Positive

Negative

Neutral

Hover marker for details

Vol.

·

Resolved Jul 19, 2026

Closed: Jul 18, 3:39 PM EST

kalshi

Kalshi

View
Join Kalshi and score $25 for your first trade.
Outcome
Trade
Chance %
Price
Spread
Liquidity
Volume
24h
7d
Open Interest
Ends in
Result
kalshi

Pittsburgh

View
100%
Yes 100¢No 0¢
100¢
N/A
$2,848,106
N/A
N/A
$1,765,419
Settled
Yes
polymarket

Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cleveland Guardians

100%
Yes 100¢No 0¢
0.1¢
N/A
$486,965
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
predict

Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cleveland Guardians

2%
Yes 2¢No 98¢
—
$1
$8,438
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
No
polymarket

O/U 7.5

100%
Yes 100¢No 0¢
0.1¢
N/A
$41,662
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

Spread -1.5

100%
Yes 100¢No 0¢
0.1¢
N/A
$22,018
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings O/U 2.5

100%
Yes 100¢No 0¢
1¢
N/A
$5
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
kalshi

Cleveland

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
100¢
N/A
$2,823,080
N/A
N/A
$1,620,746
Settled
No
polymarket

Spread -1.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$44,399
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

NRFI

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$833
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
No
polymarket

1st 5 Innings O/U 4.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$300
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings O/U 3.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$150
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

Extra Innings

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$116
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
No
polymarket

1st 5 Innings Spread -1.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$100
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings O/U 6.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$55
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings Spread -1.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$48
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings Spread -2.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$42
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings Spread -2.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$27
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
polymarket

1st 5 Innings O/U 5.5

0%
Yes 0¢No 100¢
—
N/A
$6
N/A
N/A
N/A
Settled
Yes
Total markets: 18

Intro

This market tracks whether the Pittsburgh Pirates will lead the Cleveland Guardians by at least 1.5 runs through the first five innings of their July 17, 2026 matchup. Across Predict, Kalshi, and Polymarket, the consensus probability for the Pirates covering the -1.5 spread stands at 100.0%, aggregated from real-time odds and resolved against official MLB.com scoring data. Watch the game start time of 7:10 PM ET on July 17 to see how early momentum develops, as first-five-inning spreads often hinge on opening pitching performance and lineup matchups in that critical window.

PredictionHero - Resolution Divergence Alerts (RDA)

Divergence Detected

Issue: Kalshi market contains a logical contradiction where both Pirates win and Guardians win resolve to Yes, making the market fundamentally unresolvable as a binary contract. Polymarket and Predict maintain consistent binary logic.Hero tip: Do not trade the Kalshi market in its current form. The dual-Yes resolution structure violates binary market semantics and creates settlement ambiguity. Polymarket and Predict are safe alternatives with clear, mutually exclusive outcomes.

Critical divergence points:

  • Polymarket: Standard binary winner-take-all. Pirates win resolves to Pittsburgh Pirates; Guardians win resolves to Cleveland Guardians. Postponement keeps market open; cancellation/tie/no makeup = 50-50 split. Source: Official MLB statistics within 24 hours or credible reporting consensus.
  • Predict: Identical to Polymarket. Pirates win = Pittsburgh Pirates; Guardians win = Cleveland Guardians. Postponement reopens; cancellation/tie = 50-50. Source: Official MLB final statistics within 24 hours, credible reporting fallback.
  • Kalshi: CRITICAL FLAW: Both outcomes resolve to Yes. Quote: 'If Pittsburgh wins...then the market resolves to Yes. If Cleveland wins...then the market resolves to Yes.' No clear No resolution path defined. Market is logically unresolvable.
Our PredictionHero Resolution Divergence Alerts (RDA) are there to help users identify potential differences across platforms. They do not replace or supersede the official rules and description of any prediction market. Users are solely responsible for reviewing and understanding the applicable rules and resolution criteria before placing any trade or bet. If you notice a potential inconsistency, discrepancy, or error in an alert, please report it to our team so we can review and improve the accuracy of our data.

Polymarket

In the upcoming MLB game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and Cleveland Guardians, scheduled for July 17 at 7:10PM ET: This market will resolve to "Pittsburgh Pirates" if the Pittsburgh Pirates win the game. This market will resolve to "Cleveland Guardians" if the Cleveland Guardians win the game. If the game is postponed, this market will remain open until the game has been completed. If the game is canceled entirely, with no make-up game, or ends in a tie, this market will resolve 50-50. The primary resolution source for this market is the official final statistics of the event as recognized by the governing body or event organizers. However, if the governing body or event organizers have not published final match statistics within 24 hours after the event's conclusion, a consensus of credible reporting may be used instead.

Kalshi

Resolution is based on the final result of the Pittsburgh vs Cleveland professional baseball game originally scheduled for July 17, 2026 at 7:10 PM EDT. If the game is postponed or delayed, the market remains open and closes after the rescheduled game concludes within two days. Should the game be cancelled or rescheduled to more than two days away, the market resolves to a fair price in accordance with established rules.

Predict

In the upcoming MLB game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and Cleveland Guardians, scheduled for July 17 at 7:10PM ET: This market will resolve to "Pittsburgh Pirates" if the Pittsburgh Pirates win the game. This market will resolve to "Cleveland Guardians" if the Cleveland Guardians win the game. If the game is postponed, this market will remain open until the game has been completed. If the game is canceled entirely, with no make-up game, or ends in a tie, this market will resolve 50-50. The primary resolution source for this market is the official final statistics of the event as recognized by the governing body or event organizers. However, if the governing body or event organizers have not published final match statistics within 24 hours after the event's conclusion, a consensus of credible reporting may be used instead.

Frequently asked questions

The dashboard aggregates prediction market data across Polymarket and Predict for the Pirates vs. Guardians matchup, letting you monitor real-time odds and trading volume on multiple outcomes related to this event. You'll see current probabilities, 24-hour volume trends, and cross-platform consensus as traders position themselves ahead of game time. This unified view helps you spot where the crowd is leaning and identify potential value by comparing how each venue prices the same outcomes. Total volume across platforms gives you a sense of market depth and confidence in the predictions.

Prediction markets and sportsbooks price outcomes differently because they operate under distinct incentive structures. Sportsbooks set odds to balance their book and lock in profit margins, while prediction markets aggregate trader beliefs through real-money positions. This market reflects what traders collectively believe will happen, often incorporating faster-moving information and sentiment than traditional sportsbooks. Comparing the two can reveal inefficiencies: if this market's odds diverge significantly from a major sportsbook, it may signal either emerging consensus or an opportunity for sharp bettors to exploit the gap.

Polymarket and Predict can show different implied probabilities for the same outcome because of liquidity, fee structure, participant mix, and how each venue defines the contract. Each platform attracts different trader demographics, liquidity pools, and fee structures, all of which influence how outcomes are priced. Polymarket and Predict may also have distinct user bases with varying information access or risk appetites. Additionally, timing lags between platforms mean one venue can move ahead of the other as new information emerges. These differences create arbitrage opportunities for traders monitoring both venues simultaneously, though transaction costs and withdrawal delays often limit profitable cross-platform trades.

Key catalysts include injury announcements, lineup changes, recent team performance trends, and weather conditions on game day. Betting action from sharp money or public sentiment shifts can also swing odds significantly in the hours before first pitch. Breaking news about player availability or managerial decisions often triggers rapid repricing across both platforms. Monitor sports news outlets and team social media for updates that might affect your position, and watch for volume spikes that signal informed traders entering or exiting the market ahead of the matchup.